A patent dispute may proceed simultaneously at the UPC, national courts and the EPO. Effective coordination requires a shared technical record and a separate analysis of each forum’s jurisdiction, claims, remedies and timetable. Parallel proceedings do not necessarily stop each other automatically.
In this guide: Map the proceedings precisely · Distinguish UPC allocation from international coordination · Manage the relationship with EPO proceedings · Keep technical positions consistent across forums · Design a settlement that closes the whole dispute
Map the proceedings precisely
Create a schedule identifying the parties, patent or national part, claims in issue, alleged acts, requested relief and procedural stage in each forum. Include oppositions, limitations and appeals as well as infringement litigation. Similar case names can conceal different legal entities or product versions. This map is the foundation for analysing overlap, jurisdiction, stays, settlement and the effect of later decisions.
Distinguish UPC allocation from international coordination
Article 33 contains rules for related actions between UPC divisions, including infringement, revocation and non-infringement proceedings. Coordination between the UPC and national courts also requires consideration of the Brussels I bis framework and the transitional regime. Do not transfer a rule about two UPC divisions directly to a national-court situation without checking its legal basis. The identity of the parties and cause of action can be critical.
Manage the relationship with EPO proceedings
Parties must inform the UPC of relevant pending EPO revocation, limitation or opposition proceedings and acceleration requests under Article 33(10). The UPC may stay where a rapid EPO decision is expected; the mere existence of opposition does not guarantee a stay. An EPO amendment or revocation can materially change the infringement case. Monitor decisions and procedural developments actively and assess their effect on the claims being asserted.
Keep technical positions consistent across forums
A claim interpretation advanced to avoid prior art in one forum may affect the infringement argument elsewhere. Maintain a central record of claim charts, product versions, expert evidence and amendment requests. Different legal standards may justify different submissions, but the factual account should remain accurate. Before filing, review statements made by related entities or representatives in other proceedings. Explain material differences rather than allowing unexplained contradictions to accumulate.
Design a settlement that closes the whole dispute
A commercial agreement should identify every action to be withdrawn, stayed or otherwise resolved and who must take each procedural step. Address costs, interim orders, securities, accrued damages and the treatment of EPO proceedings. If some rights or territories remain outside the settlement, describe them clearly. A global payment does not by itself terminate separate proceedings or bind an affiliate that is not a party to the agreement.
Four practical examples
These hypothetical examples explain typical decisions and evidence issues. They do not describe client matters or predict a court outcome.
1. UPC infringement while EPO opposition progresses
A proprietor sues on granted claims while an opposition hearing approaches. Both teams monitor the timetable and assess whether a rapid EPO decision may justify a stay. They also prepare for amended claims so that the infringement case can be reassessed promptly if the patent changes.
2. German litigation concerns another product version
A national case concerns an older machine, while the UPC action targets the redesigned model. The parties maintain separate product records and identify the actual overlap. Similar branding does not justify assuming that the evidence or outcome in one case automatically resolves the other.
3. Different claim interpretations in two cases
A company describes a term narrowly in validity proceedings and broadly in infringement litigation. Counsel reviews whether the positions are legally and technically reconcilable. Any legitimate alternative is explained explicitly, reducing the risk that inconsistent submissions undermine credibility.
4. A multi-country settlement leaves one action open
The parties agree royalties and withdraw the UPC action, but a national nullity case remains pending. A comprehensive settlement checklist would have identified that proceeding, the responsible party and the required filing. Closing the commercial negotiation and closing the procedural record are distinct tasks.
Related guidance
UPC Jurisdiction and Territorial Reach · Choosing a UPC Division · EPO Oppositions and Appeals · Patent Licensing, Settlement and Mediation
Legal framework and sources
Articles 33 and 83 UPCA; Brussels I bis Regulation and the applicable national procedural rules.
Agreement on a Unified Patent Court · Current UPC legal documents and Rules of Procedure
Discuss your patent matter
For an initial enquiry, identify the patent, the product or process and any known court or launch deadline. Please leave out confidential technical details until conflicts have been checked.