SEPs and FRAND Disputes

English · Deutsch · Français

Standard-essential patent disputes combine technical patent analysis with licensing and competition-law questions. The fact that a patent has been declared essential does not itself prove validity, infringement or essentiality. At the same time, the parties’ conduct during negotiations can become central to the availability of injunctive relief.

In this guide: Verify the technical case · Identify the applicable FRAND framework · Preserve a complete negotiation chronology · Evaluate rates and portfolio scope · Address supply-chain coverage and global disputes

Verify the technical case

Identify the asserted claims, relevant standard version and the provisions said to require each feature. Distinguish mandatory functionality from optional implementations and establish what the accused product actually does. Review validity independently. A declaration to a standards organisation is not a judicial finding that every compliant product infringes. Where a portfolio is offered, separate the representative patent case from the broader valuation and coverage questions.

Identify the applicable FRAND framework

FRAND commitments, competition law and contractual obligations must be analysed in context. The CJEU’s Huawei v ZTE judgment provides an important framework for certain injunction disputes involving a dominant SEP holder that has given a FRAND undertaking. The specific obligations and their application require current forum-specific analysis. A party should not reduce the framework to a checklist of formal letters while disregarding the substance and timing of negotiations.

Preserve a complete negotiation chronology

Keep notices, claim charts, requests for information, offers, counteroffers, meeting notes and responses in a coherent record. Explain delays and unresolved information needs. Assess any requirements concerning security, accounts and continued use under the applicable legal framework. Both sides should make their substantive position intelligible. A declaration of willingness to negotiate is most useful when supported by conduct that can be assessed against the circumstances.

Evaluate rates and portfolio scope

A royalty analysis should consider essentiality, validity, territory, remaining term, product coverage and the economic basis of proposed comparables. Review whether a comparable agreement includes cross-licences, litigation settlements, lump sums or other rights. The offered licence may be broader than the patent litigated. Explain why that scope and rate are appropriate or why a counterproposal better reflects the relevant circumstances. Protect confidential licence evidence while preserving meaningful scrutiny.

Address supply-chain coverage and global disputes

Determine which entity takes the licence and whether suppliers, affiliates, distributors and customers receive the intended protection. Coordinate UPC and national cases with any foreign rate-setting or contractual proceedings. Different courts may address different issues and territorial rights. Settlement drafting should deal with exhaustion and authorised downstream activity, reporting, audit, release of past claims and treatment of future portfolio changes. The litigation strategy and the licence structure need to fit the same commercial supply chain.

Four practical examples

These hypothetical examples explain typical decisions and evidence issues. They do not describe client matters or predict a court outcome.

1. Compliance does not prove every claimed feature

A device supports a communications standard, but the asserted claim is said to concern an optional mode. The implementer checks whether that mode is enabled and how it operates. The technical analysis separates the standard’s possibilities from the accused implementation, while the licensing team continues to manage the negotiation record.

2. An offer includes confidential comparables

A proprietor relies on earlier licences to justify its rate. The parties arrange appropriate confidentiality terms and examine the scope, dates and economic structure of the agreements. The comparison does not stop at the headline percentage, particularly where cross-licences or litigation settlements affect the price.

3. Supplier and customer expect the other to license

A component supplier and device manufacturer each assume the other has obtained coverage. They review the relevant contracts and actual licences, including downstream rights. The resulting allocation of responsibility is documented so that a commercial indemnity is not mistaken for patent authorisation.

4. Negotiations continue during an injunction case

The implementer submits a counteroffer and requests technical information while proceedings are pending. Counsel records the substantive reasons and timing and checks any applicable security or accounting requirements. The case is managed as an ongoing negotiation and litigation process, rather than a single exchange of formal letters.

Related guidance

Patent Infringement Actions · Defending an Infringement Claim · Confidentiality and Court Records · Patent Licensing, Settlement and Mediation

Legal framework and sources

Article 102 TFEU; CJEU C-170/13, Huawei v ZTE; applicable FRAND commitments, patent law and current forum-specific case law.

CJEU Huawei v ZTE · UPC Agreement

Discuss your patent matter

For an initial enquiry, identify the patent, the product or process and any known court or launch deadline. Please leave out confidential technical details until conflicts have been checked.