Trade Fair Patent Disputes

English · Deutsch · Français

Trade fairs concentrate commercial opportunity and patent litigation risk into a short period. Exhibits, demonstrations and offers may become evidence, while urgent proceedings can disrupt the event. Effective preparation starts before travel and requires a coordinated legal and operational plan for the specific products being shown.

In this guide: Assess the exhibition activity, not only sales · Check the patents and available forums · Prepare the evidence package in advance · Create a service and incident protocol · Separate immediate response from the longer dispute

Assess the exhibition activity, not only sales

A business may assume that no infringement risk exists because it will not complete sales at the booth. Patent analysis also needs to consider offers, demonstrations, imports, storage and intended use. The legal significance depends on the actual conduct and territorial connection. Review brochures, order forms, website links and demonstration scripts alongside the physical exhibit. A product labelled ‘prototype’ or ‘not for sale’ does not automatically resolve every issue.

Check the patents and available forums

Identify the relevant rights, current claims, ownership, expiry and opt-out status. A German event can raise UPC issues, German national patent issues and utility-model issues, each with different procedural routes. Do not assume a single protective filing covers all potential claims. Where several patents are involved, prioritise by technical relevance and the practical risk to the exhibition. Keep a short evidence-based assessment for each product-right combination.

Prepare the evidence package in advance

For a potential claimant, record what is lawfully observable, the identity of the exhibitor, the model and the date. Preserve catalogues and public demonstrations accurately. Do not enter restricted areas or obtain confidential information without authority. For a potential defendant, keep product specifications, relevant prior art, licence documents and the claim analysis available to the response team. If the exhibit differs from the sold product, document the difference before the event.

Create a service and incident protocol

Nominate a responsible manager and legal contact who can be reached during the fair. Train staff to preserve documents, note times and identify the person serving them, without making admissions or obstructing lawful measures. Arrange access to translations where needed. A court order must be read precisely: the affected models, prohibited acts, timing and enforcement conditions matter. Commercial staff should not decide on their own that removing a brochure or changing a label is sufficient compliance.

Separate immediate response from the longer dispute

The urgent objective may be to preserve the event, comply with an order or secure evidence, but the patent dispute can continue after the fair closes. Plan any review, appeal and merits proceedings, and preserve records of cancelled meetings, removed exhibits and mitigation costs. If a temporary commercial agreement is reached, define its duration, products and territories. Avoid a hurried undertaking that unintentionally restricts future products or markets beyond the immediate concern.

Four practical examples

These hypothetical examples explain typical decisions and evidence issues. They do not describe client matters or predict a court outcome.

1. An overseas exhibitor brings a demonstration unit

A manufacturer imports a machine for display and publishes an order contact at its booth. Counsel examines the import, demonstration and offering facts rather than assuming that the absence of completed sales eliminates risk. The team checks the exact unit and prepares a response for the patent most closely related to its mechanism.

2. A brochure depicts an older model

A claimant photographs a brochure showing a feature no longer present in the exhibit. Before seeking relief, the team establishes whether the brochure amounts to an offer of that model and whether the displayed unit uses the feature. The two factual routes are kept distinct instead of treating one picture as proof of every allegation.

3. Service during a live demonstration

Booth staff receive court documents while customers are present. They contact the designated response team, preserve the documents and record the time. Counsel checks the operative order and coordinates any necessary change to the demonstration. The staff protocol reduces the risk of accidental non-compliance or inaccurate statements made under pressure.

4. A temporary standstill agreement

Two competitors agree to suspend a particular demonstration while investigating a claim. The agreement identifies the exhibit, event dates and reserved legal positions. It addresses whether online offers and later deliveries are covered. This prevents a narrow event-management solution from becoming an unintended worldwide product restriction.

Related guidance

Preliminary Injunctions · Protective Letters · Evidence Preservation and Inspections · German Patent Infringement Litigation

Legal framework and sources

Articles 25–26 and 60–62 UPCA; national patent and utility-model rules where applicable.

Agreement on a Unified Patent Court · Current UPC legal documents and Rules of Procedure

Discuss your patent matter

For an initial enquiry, identify the patent, the product or process and any known court or launch deadline. Please leave out confidential technical details until conflicts have been checked.