Patent litigation may require disclosure of the very information a business needs to keep confidential. UPC procedure distinguishes protection of sensitive evidence within the case from public access to court records. Both issues should be addressed before filing, with specific requests and a workable system for handling documents.
In this guide: Identify what is actually confidential · Seek protection that permits a fair defence · Treat public file access as a separate question · Maintain consistent document versions · Address hearings, judgments and later use
Identify what is actually confidential
Review technical drawings, source code, process parameters, licence terms, customer lists and personal data before they enter the case. Explain the nature of the information, who already knows it and the harm that disclosure could cause. A label applied to every document is less persuasive than a reasoned assessment. Separate material already public from genuinely sensitive content. This makes it easier to propose proportionate protection without obscuring the technical issue the court must decide.
Seek protection that permits a fair defence
Article 58 UPCA allows restrictions on the collection, use and access to evidence. A confidentiality regime must also respect the other party’s ability to understand and answer the case. Consider which lawyers, experts and party representatives need access, what undertakings are appropriate and how disputes about designation will be resolved. Do not assume that an ‘external lawyers only’ arrangement will always be available or sufficient. The requested regime must fit the facts and applicable procedural safeguards.
Treat public file access as a separate question
Public access to written pleadings and evidence is governed by the applicable court-record rules, including the reasoned-request framework. It should not be confused with access by the opposing party for the purpose of defending the case. Prepare reasoned confidentiality requests and suitable redacted versions where required. A commercially sensitive document may need protection even where the litigation itself is public. Conversely, the mere fact that material appears in a patent dispute does not automatically make it secret.
Maintain consistent document versions
Use clear naming and version control for confidential originals, redacted versions and documents approved for wider circulation. Check exhibits, filenames, embedded comments and metadata for unintended disclosure. Ensure that experts and translation providers receive only what their authorised role requires. Redactions should preserve enough context to understand the argument. A poorly managed confidentiality process can create both procedural confusion and an irreversible commercial disclosure.
Address hearings, judgments and later use
Sensitive issues may arise in oral submissions, demonstrations and the wording of a judgment. Raise these matters in time rather than waiting until confidential information is being discussed publicly. Review the permitted use of material in parallel litigation, licensing negotiations and internal reporting. A document obtained under a court order should not automatically be reused elsewhere. At the end of the case, follow any continuing obligations concerning retention, return, deletion or restricted access.
Four practical examples
These hypothetical examples explain typical decisions and evidence issues. They do not describe client matters or predict a court outcome.
1. Source code supports a non-infringement defence
A defendant needs to explain a software operation without disclosing an entire codebase to its competitor. It identifies the relevant modules and requests a tailored access regime. The proposal allows meaningful technical scrutiny while excluding unrelated code. The defence remains evidentially usable instead of relying on a bare assertion that the software works differently.
2. Licence comparables contain negotiated pricing
A party relies on comparable licence agreements in a royalty dispute. It identifies the commercially sensitive clauses and considers redactions and controlled access. The court and the opposing party still need enough information to assess comparability, including scope and economic terms. Excessive redaction can undermine the very evidence being relied on.
3. A third party seeks access to pleadings
A non-party makes a reasoned request for written pleadings. The litigant assesses the applicable access rules and explains specific confidentiality interests rather than assuming that every filing remains private. A prepared redacted version helps separate the public legal argument from genuinely sensitive technical or commercial information.
4. An expert presentation reveals a process parameter
A hearing slide contains a confidential manufacturing setting in a diagram annotation. The team identifies it during a pre-hearing review and addresses presentation and access arrangements in advance. The example illustrates why confidentiality review must include graphics and oral evidence, not only the main written pleading.
Related guidance
Evidence Preservation and Inspections · Orders to Produce Evidence · SEPs and FRAND Disputes · Software, AI and Electronics Patents
Legal framework and sources
Articles 45 and 58 UPCA; Rules 262 and 262A of the UPC Rules of Procedure.
Agreement on a Unified Patent Court · Current UPC legal documents and Rules of Procedure
Discuss your patent matter
For an initial enquiry, identify the patent, the product or process and any known court or launch deadline. Please leave out confidential technical details until conflicts have been checked.