Revocation Counterclaims

English · Deutsch · Français

A revocation counterclaim brings patent validity into an existing UPC infringement dispute. It should be prepared as a complete technical case and coordinated with the non-infringement defence. Its value depends on whether the challenged claims—and the proprietor’s possible amendments—cover the business activity at risk.

In this guide: Choose the procedural route early · Understand the division’s options · Build attacks that answer the actual claims · Keep claim interpretation consistent · Use the counterclaim in settlement planning

Choose the procedural route early

An infringement defendant should investigate validity as soon as the claim is received. The counterclaim has its own procedural requirements, fee implications and evidence needs. Confirm the correct proprietor and how the counterclaim must be directed where the infringement claimant is a licensee. Do not postpone prior-art work until the non-infringement pleading is complete. The initial timetable can make a sequential approach impractical, especially where several patents or product versions are asserted.

Understand the division’s options

Under Article 33(3) UPCA, a local or regional division may hear infringement and revocation together with a technically qualified judge, refer the counterclaim to the central division while continuing or suspending infringement, or refer the entire case with the parties’ agreement. The parties can make submissions on the suitable course, but should not assume that a counterclaim necessarily produces bifurcation or an automatic stay. The practical consequences for timing and technical presentation should be considered in the defence strategy.

Build attacks that answer the actual claims

Separate novelty, inventive-step, sufficiency and added-matter objections. Identify the relevant disclosure and explain why it satisfies the legal test. For an inventive-step argument, state the technical starting point, the distinguishing features and why the claimed solution would have been obvious. For insufficiency, identify the substantive difficulty across the claim scope and support it with evidence where appropriate. Merely calling a claim ‘unclear’ does not establish an independent ground of revocation.

Keep claim interpretation consistent

A defendant should test whether its validity position depends on a different reading of the claim from its infringement position. Alternative arguments can be legitimate, but their relationship should be made explicit. The proprietor may seek amendments to answer the counterclaim. Analyse support in the original application, the scope of protection and whether the amended claim still reads on the accused product. Updated technical comparisons may be needed during the written procedure.

Use the counterclaim in settlement planning

The counterclaim can change the dispute from a bilateral damages claim into a risk to the patent itself. That may affect settlement incentives and the interests of licensees. Assess the value of a licence, covenant not to sue or product-specific agreement against the potential outcome on validity. Any settlement should address the procedural treatment of both the infringement action and counterclaim, costs, existing interim orders and the consequences for related proceedings.

Four practical examples

These hypothetical examples explain typical decisions and evidence issues. They do not describe client matters or predict a court outcome.

1. Infringement asserted by a licensee

An exclusive licensee sues over a packaging mechanism. The defendant plans a counterclaim against the patent’s validity and checks the procedural role of the proprietor. This avoids treating the licensee’s enforcement position as equivalent to ownership and ensures that the revocation case is directed against the appropriate party.

2. A claim narrowed during the case

The proprietor adds a dependent feature requiring a particular temperature range. The defendant reassesses both the original disclosure and its product’s real operating conditions. A laboratory test at an artificial setting would not necessarily establish how the commercial product works, so test evidence and usage data are considered together.

3. Parallel technical arguments

The defendant argues that a claim requires a specific feedback loop which its product lacks. It also argues that, if the claim is interpreted more broadly, earlier control systems anticipate it. The pleadings explain these alternatives transparently. This prevents the validity case from appearing to rest on an unexplained change in claim interpretation.

4. Settlement with an unresolved counterclaim

The parties agree a licence in principle. Their settlement must still deal with the revocation counterclaim, any interim relief, costs and related EPO proceedings. A payment clause alone would leave procedural and commercial uncertainty. The final agreement is therefore matched to the steps required in each affected forum.

Related guidance

Defending an Infringement Claim · Standalone Revocation Actions · Claim Construction and Equivalents · Patent Licensing, Settlement and Mediation

Legal framework and sources

Articles 33(3), 47 and 65 UPCA; Article 138 EPC.

Agreement on a Unified Patent Court · Current UPC legal documents and Rules of Procedure

Discuss your patent matter

For an initial enquiry, identify the patent, the product or process and any known court or launch deadline. Please leave out confidential technical details until conflicts have been checked.