Direct and indirect infringement address different forms of participation in the use of a patented invention. The analysis must connect a defined act, a particular company and the relevant territory to the technical scope of the patent. Supply-chain position alone does not determine liability.
In this guide: Analyse the direct acts separately · Identify the requirements for indirect infringement · Assess knowledge, instructions and ordinary products · Check permissions and limitations · Frame evidence and remedies for the actual conduct
Analyse the direct acts separately
Article 25 UPCA addresses acts involving patented products, processes and products obtained directly by patented processes. Manufacturing, offering, marketing, using, importing and storing may each require a distinct factual analysis. Identify what the defendant actually did and which claim category is involved. A retailer’s offer, an importer’s shipment and a manufacturer’s production should not be collapsed into one undifferentiated allegation.
Identify the requirements for indirect infringement
Article 26 concerns supplying or offering means relating to an essential element of the invention for putting it into effect in the relevant territory, with the required knowledge of suitability and intended use. A component need not itself contain every claim feature for indirect infringement to arise. Conversely, supplying any item used somewhere in a patented system is not enough. Analyse the essential-element connection, intended implementation and territorial requirements carefully.
Assess knowledge, instructions and ordinary products
Product instructions, technical support, marketing and customer communications can be important evidence of intended use and knowledge. The Agreement treats staple commercial products differently, subject to the inducement qualification. A warning in small print may not resolve a situation in which the supplier actively promotes the patented use. Equally, the mere possibility that a general-purpose item could be used in an infringing way does not establish every statutory requirement.
Check permissions and limitations
Review licences, authorised sales, exhaustion, prior-use rights and statutory exceptions on their own terms. A customer contract may allocate liability without granting patent permission. The scope of any authorisation can depend on product, use, territory and supply-chain coverage. Establish who granted it and whether that person had the relevant rights. Avoid assuming that an upstream purchase automatically permits every downstream combination or process.
Frame evidence and remedies for the actual conduct
A direct-infringement claim and an indirect-infringement claim may require different evidence and differently framed relief. Collect the component specifications, installation instructions, customer configuration and relevant communications. For a defence, identify substantial lawful uses and any technical or contractual measures actually implemented. An appropriate solution may involve a genuine product modification or changes to supply conditions, but its adequacy must be assessed against the legal requirements and the order sought.
Four practical examples
These hypothetical examples explain typical decisions and evidence issues. They do not describe client matters or predict a court outcome.
1. A specialised module is supplied for a patented system
A supplier sells a module that lacks several elements of the complete system claim. The analysis considers indirect infringement, including the module’s relationship to an essential element and evidence of the intended combination. The absence of every claim feature from the module alone does not end the inquiry.
2. A general-purpose chemical has several uses
A distributor sells a widely used chemical, and one customer employs it in a patented process. Counsel examines the staple-product rule, the distributor’s knowledge and any inducement. Marketing and technical advice are reviewed alongside the product’s ordinary uses rather than inferring liability solely from one customer’s conduct.
3. Installation instructions complete the picture
A device is delivered with instructions directing the customer to combine it with specified equipment. Those instructions may be significant to the intended-use analysis. The legal team checks the actual supplied version and customer configuration, avoiding reliance on an obsolete manual.
4. An upstream licence has limited coverage
A component is manufactured under a licence, but the downstream use involves a separate system patent. The parties examine the licence and relevant exhaustion issues rather than treating the licensed component as universal clearance. Supply contracts and indemnities are then aligned with the remaining risk.
Related guidance
Product and Process Patents · Claim Construction and Equivalents · Patent Infringement Actions · Patent Licensing, Settlement and Mediation
Legal framework and sources
Articles 25–29 UPCA.
Agreement on a Unified Patent Court · Current UPC legal documents and Rules of Procedure
Discuss your patent matter
For an initial enquiry, identify the patent, the product or process and any known court or launch deadline. Please leave out confidential technical details until conflicts have been checked.