Preliminary Injunctions

English · Deutsch · Français

A UPC preliminary injunction can affect a product launch or supply chain before the full infringement action is decided. The application must explain why interim intervention is necessary and support the patent, infringement and urgency case with evidence. For defendants, a prompt and technically specific response is essential.

In this guide: Identify the precise interim objective · Prepare validity and infringement together · Document urgency and the knowledge chronology · Address the balance of interests and safeguards · Plan the next procedural and operational steps

Identify the precise interim objective

An application should state which conduct needs to stop, which products are affected and why a later judgment would not adequately address the situation. Consider whether an injunction, seizure or a narrower measure is appropriate. The requested order must be capable of practical implementation. A broad description of a technology platform may create uncertainty over products that were never analysed. Link the proposed relief to the proven or imminent conduct and the patent’s relevant territorial effect.

Prepare validity and infringement together

Article 62 UPCA and Rule 211 frame the assessment of provisional measures. The court considers the evidential basis for entitlement, validity and actual or imminent infringement. Patent grant alone does not replace a case-specific validity analysis. Address material prior art, opposition history and known objections. On infringement, provide a clear claim chart and explain any inaccessible technical features. An urgent application is weakened if its central technical proposition depends on an unsupported assumption.

Document urgency and the knowledge chronology

Keep a dated record of when the accused activity became known, what was investigated and why each step was necessary. The court considers unreasonable delay. There is no safe general rule that a business can wait until the last convenient date before a launch or trade fair. Conversely, a claimant may need time to obtain and examine reliable evidence. Explain that work with documents and a coherent chronology, rather than relying on a general assertion that the matter is urgent.

Address the balance of interests and safeguards

Explain the likely harm if relief is granted and if it is refused. Relevant practical issues may include market entry, price effects, customer dependence, replacement products and the reversibility of the measure. Consider security and the potential compensation consequences of an unjustified injunction. Without-notice relief requires additional justification for proceeding without hearing the other party. It should not be presented as an automatic consequence of urgency or as the standard way to obtain a commercial advantage.

Plan the next procedural and operational steps

Interim proceedings do not eliminate the need to manage the merits action and applicable follow-on deadlines. For applicants, organise security, service and enforcement before assuming the order will have practical effect. For defendants, assess review, appeal, suspension and compliance as separate workstreams. Preserve evidence of any losses and mitigation steps. A settlement during the interim phase should deal expressly with the order, security, stock and the future treatment of the patent dispute.

Four practical examples

These hypothetical examples explain typical decisions and evidence issues. They do not describe client matters or predict a court outcome.

1. A launch announced before products are available

A competitor announces a launch and supplies detailed specifications but no purchasable sample. The applicant separates what the announcement actually proves from what remains uncertain and examines whether infringement is sufficiently imminent. The proposed relief is based on the identified product and evidence, rather than a speculative claim against all future models.

2. Investigation explains part of the elapsed time

A patent owner needs laboratory analysis to establish a hidden formulation feature. It records sample purchase, delivery, testing and receipt of results. That chronology helps explain the investigation, while earlier knowledge and any inactive periods still require scrutiny. A laboratory report is useful only if the tested sample can be linked to the accused product.

3. A defendant depends on confidential process data

The applicant infers infringement from the final product, but the defendant uses a different process. The defendant prepares a technically meaningful response and seeks suitable confidentiality protection for the supporting manufacturing records. Simply refusing to explain the process may leave an important factual allegation unanswered.

4. An injunction would interrupt critical supply

A defendant explains the effect of a requested order on existing customer operations and identifies possible substitute products or transition arrangements. The court still assesses infringement, validity and the applicable legal conditions. Concrete evidence of the consequences is more useful than a general statement that an injunction would be commercially damaging.

Related guidance

Protective Letters · Trade Fair Patent Disputes · Evidence Preservation and Inspections · UPC Appeals

Legal framework and sources

Article 62 UPCA; Rules 206–213 of the UPC Rules of Procedure.

Agreement on a Unified Patent Court · Current UPC legal documents and Rules of Procedure

Discuss your patent matter

For an initial enquiry, identify the patent, the product or process and any known court or launch deadline. Please leave out confidential technical details until conflicts have been checked.