UPC enforcement during appeal: an EPO revocation does not automatically suspend an injunction

horak Rechtsanwälte · Patent insights and case law

English · Deutsch · Français

Businesses facing a UPC injunction must manage two questions separately: whether the decision should be overturned and what must happen while the appeal is pending. A favourable development at the EPO is important, but it should not be treated as an operational permission to ignore an enforceable order. A November 2026 decision illustrates the distinction.

The decision of 2 November 2026

In Netflix v DivX, UPC_CoA_176/2026 and 177/2026, the Court of Appeal refused suspensive effect. A non-final EPO revocation did not itself justify suspension where the Local Division had already considered the underlying validity arguments. The order’s treatment of parallel proceedings is case-specific; it does not make EPO developments irrelevant or establish that suspension can never be obtained.

Maintain separate litigation and compliance plans

Our practical recommendation is to prepare an appeal plan and an operational compliance plan at the same time. The first identifies contested findings and available procedural applications. The second identifies affected products, conduct, territories, entities and implementation responsibilities. Keep a clear record of which obligations arise from the operative order and which precautions are voluntary business choices. Product teams need actionable instructions, not only a forecast of appellate prospects.

When an EPO decision arrives, compare its reasoning and procedural status with the UPC record. Identify the claims considered, the material relied on, whether reasons are available and what further proceedings remain possible. A headline that the patent has been revoked can conceal significant procedural qualifications. Counsel should assess whether and how the development supports a specific application, rather than simply forwarding the result as if it altered the existing order automatically.

Document the real commercial consequences

For an application concerning enforcement, the business team should supply reliable evidence of stock, customer commitments, technical changeover, alternative supply and consequences that cannot readily be reversed. Distinguish quantified losses from assumptions. Explain what mitigation is available and what it costs. The litigation team can then evaluate which facts matter under the applicable standard. These preparation suggestions are not a prediction that any particular commercial hardship will secure suspension.

Four hypothetical practical examples

The following scenarios are illustrative and are not facts attributed to Netflix or DivX.

1. A product delivery scheduled after judgment

A supplier has a shipment due before the appeal can be heard. Operations identify the affected configuration and contractual commitments while counsel examines procedural relief. The delivery team is told which conduct remains prohibited unless the court changes the position; the appeal filing is not treated as an automatic clearance.

2. An opposition result without written reasons

An EPO division announces revocation, but the detailed reasons are not yet available. Counsel records the actual result and status, obtains the relevant procedural documents and compares the arguments with the UPC decision. Internal reporting separates the favourable development from any conclusion about immediate enforceability.

3. A redesign proposed during the appeal

Engineers offer a modified implementation to preserve supply. It receives its own claim analysis and version designation. Existing stock is separated from the redesign, and installation teams receive clear instructions. The business does not assume that the redesign is lawful merely because the original decision is being challenged.

4. Evidence of irreversible disruption

A customer-dependent process may be difficult to restart after interruption. The company documents the practical steps, timescales and available alternatives, with support from responsible technical personnel. It distinguishes verified operational consequences from general statements about market damage so that counsel can assess the relevant argument precisely.

Board-level reporting

A useful report distinguishes the current order, appeal status, EPO status, pending applications and authorised operational steps. Update it after each material event and record who approves changes. Settlement discussions should also address the existing order, securities and stock. Keeping these strands separate avoids turning a promising legal development into an unsupported instruction to resume prohibited conduct.

Primary source

Court order: document copy · UPC legal documents

Discuss your procedural position