UPC confidentiality in 2026: public access and opponent access need separate protection

horak Rechtsanwälte · Patent insights and case law

English · Deutsch · Français

Confidentiality is not a single switch in UPC proceedings. Preventing public access to a document and restricting how the opposing party accesses or uses information involve distinct questions. A company preparing evidence should identify the required protection before filing, rather than assume that a confidentiality label or a public-access request covers every risk.

The order of 5 November 2026

In Disney v InterDigital, UPC_CoA_133/2026 and 134/2026, the Court distinguished Rule 262.2 from Rule 262A. A request under Rule 262.2 did not automatically restrict disclosure by the opponent. Rule 262A protection sought for the first time on appeal was inadmissible for material already submitted below. Newly disclosed material required identification; the order did not declare every confidentiality request inadmissible.

Start with the information, not the label

Our recommendation is to classify the actual information before selecting a procedural request. A document may combine public technical facts, confidential customer terms and data belonging to another business. Identify the passages requiring protection and explain the harm that disclosure or use could cause. A blanket confidential stamp does not tell the legal team which interests need protection or why the proposed restrictions are proportionate.

Keep separate records for public-file restrictions, access by the opposing party, permitted use, hearing arrangements and any contractual confidentiality obligations. These mechanisms may interact but should not be treated as interchangeable. Check who is already entitled to the information and what an existing agreement actually covers. The fact that negotiations occurred under an NDA does not eliminate the need to assess the procedural protection required for filed material.

Prepare the filing package together with the request

The practical workflow should join substantive drafting and confidentiality review. Prepare clean identification of the relevant passages, suitable redacted versions and the requested access arrangements in time for filing. Check translations, annexes and quotations in the main pleading: sensitive information can reappear outside the document originally marked confidential. Keep a record of existing orders and their scope so that later submissions do not rely on a protection regime that never covered them.

Four hypothetical practical examples

These illustrations are not additional facts from the Disney proceedings and do not describe client matters.

1. A pricing schedule in a licence exhibit

A company needs a licence agreement as evidence, but only some commercial terms are sensitive. Counsel identifies the precise schedule and explains the commercial interest. The team considers public redactions and the appropriate party-access restrictions separately, instead of assuming that hiding the agreement from the public settles every confidentiality issue.

2. Source code quoted in the pleading

An engineer marks a source-code annex confidential, while the draft pleading reproduces the decisive passages. A cross-document check identifies both locations. The request and redacted versions are prepared consistently so that protection does not depend on the sensitive passage appearing only in the originally labelled exhibit.

3. A new document in the appeal

The appeal includes a document not previously filed. The team distinguishes genuinely new information from passages already submitted at first instance and checks the applicable orders. It identifies the new material precisely rather than seeking a single undifferentiated protection order for the entire appeal bundle.

4. A third-party manufacturing agreement

A defendant relies on a supplier agreement containing confidential technical commitments. Before filing, counsel checks the agreement, the evidential need and the proposed protection. The company coordinates with the supplier without promising that an NDA alone determines the Court’s access regime or removes the opponent’s procedural rights.

Make confidentiality review an assigned responsibility

Appoint an owner for the information inventory and give the legal team sufficient time to prepare the application. Track which versions were filed and which persons may receive protected material under the actual order. If a hearing or a new filing changes the situation, reassess it promptly. Specific, timely requests are more useful than broad statements that everything in the dispute is commercially sensitive.

Primary source

Court order: document copy · UPC legal documents

Discuss your procedural position