SEP and FRAND disputes in 2026: prepare the negotiation file before litigation

horak Rechtsanwälte · Patent insights and case law

English · Deutsch · Français

A standard-essential patent dispute has two connected records: the technical case and the licensing negotiations. Weakness in either can undermine a sensible commercial position. This 2026 practice guide explains how to organise both records without presenting historic case law as a new judgment or assuming that a standards declaration proves infringement.

The legal starting point

The CJEU’s Huawei v ZTE judgment dates from 16 July 2015, not 2026. It addresses injunctions involving a dominant SEP holder that has given a FRAND commitment and sets a framework for the parties’ conduct. Its application requires attention to the particular dispute and the relevant court. [1] Patent infringement, validity and licensing scope must still be analysed separately.

Give the negotiation file an owner

Appoint a person to maintain a dated chronology of notices, technical explanations, requests for clarification, offers and responses. Record who received each communication and which attachments were actually provided. A spreadsheet stating “offer rejected” is less useful than the underlying offer, the reason for rejection and the information requested to evaluate it. Preserve meeting notes promptly and identify any disputed account of what was said.

The licensing team should explain its commercial assumptions to litigation counsel early. Which products and affiliates need coverage? Is the proposal based on units, turnover, a lump sum or a combination? What happens when the portfolio changes? Identify missing information in precise terms rather than issuing a general demand for everything. Equally, a patent holder should be able to explain how the proposed scope relates to the business being approached.

Keep technical and commercial analysis connected

Prepare a claim comparison for the particular patent and standard version. Ask engineers to distinguish mandatory features from optional modes and to identify the accused implementation. In parallel, keep a schedule of the patents and territories included in the proposed licence. This prevents a discussion about one claim from being confused with the price of an entire international portfolio.

Comparables require a structured reading. Record whether an agreement includes cross-licences, releases, litigation costs or other commercial consideration before treating its headline rate as comparable. Organise confidential material through appropriate access arrangements. Where information cannot yet be shared, identify the practical obstacle and a proposed way forward rather than allowing an unexplained gap to persist in the record.

Four practical examples

1. A feature exists only in an optional mode

A connected device supports a standard but ships with the disputed mode disabled. Engineers preserve configuration records and explain which versions enable it. Counsel can then separate the actual technical allegation from the broader commercial reason to seek a portfolio licence.

2. An offer reaches the wrong company

A group’s purchasing subsidiary receives a proposal concerning products sold by several affiliates. The group identifies the intended licensee, routes the proposal to the responsible team and records that process. Organisational confusion is addressed before it becomes an unexplained period of silence.

3. A supplier’s indemnity is mistaken for a licence

A manufacturer finds an indemnity clause and assumes all patent use is authorised. The team checks the actual licences, covered products and downstream rights. It distinguishes allocation of financial risk from permission to use the technology and identifies any remaining gap.

4. A counteroffer changes the royalty base

The parties discuss similar percentages applied to different revenue measures. A calculation using the same sample sales exposes the difference. The counteroffer explains its assumptions, allowing the negotiation record to show the real commercial disagreement rather than merely competing figures.

Before an injunction hearing

Reconcile the chronology with the correspondence and technical file. Confirm that counsel knows which proposals remain open, what information has arrived and whether security or accounting questions need attention. Negotiations can continue during proceedings; the record should reflect developments rather than freezing at the filing date.

Practical guide reviewed on 17 November 2026. The examples are hypothetical and do not describe client matters.

Official sources

1. https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX%3A62013CJ0170

2. https://curia.europa.eu/jcms/upload/docs/application/pdf/2015-07/cp150088en.pdf

Discuss your patent matter

Please identify the patent, the affected product and any known deadline. Do not send confidential technical details before conflicts have been checked. Contact our team