Cross-border patent enforcement in 2026: build the jurisdiction map after BSH

horak Rechtsanwälte · Patent insights and case law

English · Deutsch · Français

An international sales network does not produce a single, self-explanatory patent case. Before selecting a court, a business needs a map of the rights, alleged acts, defendants and remedies. This 2026 practice guide uses the BSH framework to explain why the infringement case and the validity challenge must be planned together but not conflated.

What BSH does, and does not, establish

The CJEU decided BSH Hausgeräte v Electrolux, C-339/22, on 25 February 2025. A court at the defendant’s EU domicile can retain infringement jurisdiction despite a validity defence concerning another Member State’s patent; exclusive validity jurisdiction remains distinct. The judgment also addresses third-country patents without authorising alteration of the foreign register. It is not a worldwide patent or unrestricted global revocation power. [1]

The Brussels I bis rules and the UPC Agreement require separate attention when choosing the forum. UPC subject-matter competence and transitional arrangements cannot simply be inferred from the existence of an EU defendant. [2] [3] [4] The practical analysis should identify the legal basis for each proposed claim, rather than beginning with the desired territorial reach of the injunction.

Construct a country and defendant schedule

List the relevant patent in each country, the claim version, proprietor, expiry and pending proceedings. Record opt-outs where relevant and distinguish Unitary Patents from conventional European and national rights. Add the entities that manufacture, import, offer and sell the actual product. A parent company’s location is useful information, but it does not itself prove that every group member performed every alleged act.

Prepare a separate claim comparison where the granted wording or product differs. Record which evidence supports each alleged act and where that evidence can lawfully be obtained. Identify the applicable language and any need for local technical or legal input. This makes the proposed case reviewable before procedural deadlines and translation costs begin to shape the strategy by default.

Coordinate validity, evidence and settlement

Discuss how a validity challenge may affect timing and case management. Do not assume that winning one proceeding automatically resolves every other country. Keep a shared factual chronology, while allowing national counsel to explain differences in law and proof. Documents obtained under one court’s confidentiality or use restrictions should be checked before they are circulated into another case.

For settlement, use the same territorial schedule to define patents, companies, product versions and periods covered. Address existing orders, costs and steps needed to close each proceeding. A global commercial price does not eliminate the need for precise releases and licences. Identify excluded rights expressly, especially where a pending divisional or a future product generation could otherwise revive the disagreement.

Four practical examples

1. A European family contains different claims

The patent asserted in Germany includes a feature absent from a related claim elsewhere. The team prepares separate comparisons instead of copying the first infringement chart. It can then explain which product versions matter in each country and why the cases are not identical.

2. A distributor is confused with a manufacturer

Sales documents name a local distributor, while production takes place at an unrelated supplier. Counsel maps the actual conduct and proposed defendants. The company relationship is investigated, not assumed from a shared product brochure or the presence of a local website.

3. A validity defence concerns a third-country patent

A defendant challenges a foreign patent during an EU infringement action. The team analyses the precise jurisdictional basis and the effect of the requested decision. It does not describe an inter partes assessment as deletion of the foreign patent from its register.

4. Evidence is useful but restricted

A process description obtained under a confidentiality order would assist another national case. Before transfer, counsel checks the order and seeks any required permission. The evidence plan preserves its potential value without creating a separate procedural problem through unauthorised disclosure.

Practical guide reviewed on 17 November 2026. The examples are hypothetical and do not describe client matters.

Official sources

1. https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX%3A62022CJ0339

2. https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2012/1215/oj/deu

3. https://www.epo.org/en/legal/up-upc/2022/upca_32.html

4. https://www.epo.org/en/legal/up-upc/2022/upca_83.html

Discuss your patent matter

Please identify the patent, the affected product and any known deadline. Do not send confidential technical details before conflicts have been checked. Contact our team