A successful UPC infringement action connects a precise technical case with a commercially useful remedy. The starting point is not the number of countries in a patent portfolio, but the product or process that matters, the companies responsible for the relevant acts, and the business outcome the proceedings should achieve.
In this guide: Establish the right to sue and the patent’s scope · Build an infringement case that can be proved · Identify defendants, territories and requested relief · Prepare for the validity challenge · Manage the case as a business decision

Establish the right to sue and the patent’s scope
Before preparing the statement of claim, verify the patent’s current claims, ownership history, territorial effect and any opt-out. Check amendments made in opposition or limitation proceedings and identify supplementary protection certificates where relevant. An exclusive licensee’s position must be assessed against Article 47 UPCA and the licence; a non-exclusive licensee needs the contractual authority required by that provision. Register entries, assignments and licence clauses should tell a consistent story. A strong technical case can otherwise be delayed by an avoidable dispute about standing.
Build an infringement case that can be proved
Prepare a feature-by-feature claim chart with separate columns for the claim wording, its interpretation, the accused implementation and supporting evidence. A brochure may show what a product promises, but not how its internal components operate. Record the model, firmware, serial number, purchase route and test conditions. Distinguish observed facts from expert inferences. For a process implemented inside a factory or server environment, consider targeted evidence measures early. Do not assume that a visually similar product uses the patented technical teaching.
Identify defendants, territories and requested relief
Making, offering, marketing, using, importing and storing can involve different companies. Plead the relevant conduct of each defendant rather than treating a corporate group as a single actor. Examine the jurisdictional basis and division competence separately. The requested injunction should match the patent, the infringing embodiments and the legally available territorial reach. Consider information, corrective measures, damages and costs alongside the injunction. These remedies require their own factual support; they are not a substitute for defining the core infringement accurately.
Prepare for the validity challenge
An infringement action often provokes a revocation counterclaim. Review the closest prior art, priority entitlement, disclosure of the claimed invention and any added-matter issue before filing. Test whether a narrower claim would still cover the accused product. A commercial objective such as keeping a competitor out of a key product segment may depend on a specific dependent claim rather than the broadest claim. Coordinate technical evidence, expert instructions and possible amendment positions so that infringement and validity arguments remain consistent.
Manage the case as a business decision
The written case must be prepared early. Assign responsibility for product evidence, sales information, technical witnesses and internal approvals. Budget for a counterclaim, expert work, translations, security and an appeal rather than only the initial filing. Evaluate settlement milestones against the product life cycle: an agreement before a launch may have a different value from damages after the product has been replaced. Keep a separate implementation plan for any injunction, licence or settlement so that the outcome can be acted on promptly.
Four practical examples
These hypothetical examples explain typical decisions and evidence issues. They do not describe client matters or predict a court outcome.
1. Competing industrial pump
A manufacturer purchases the competitor’s current pump through a distributor. The external housing resembles the patented design, but infringement turns on an internal flow passage. The sample is documented before a controlled teardown and the relevant dimensions are measured. This allows the pleading to identify the actual sold embodiment and avoids relying on an advertising drawing that may depict an earlier model.
2. Exclusive licence with reserved rights
A European distributor holds an exclusive licence, while the proprietor has retained certain enforcement rights. Before filing, the parties review the licence, notification requirements and who should claim which losses. Resolving this at the outset prevents the proceedings from becoming a dispute about authority and ensures that the commercial settlement can bind the necessary rights holders.
3. Several companies in one supply chain
A non-European manufacturer supplies a European importer and separate national retailers. The claim identifies the importer’s shipments, the retailers’ offers and the manufacturer’s alleged conduct individually. The jurisdictional analysis then tests the intended combination of defendants. Corporate affiliation alone is not used as proof that every entity committed every alleged act.
4. A narrower claim that still matters
Prior art creates a serious risk for claim 1, but a dependent claim contains a feature used in the competitor’s premium model. The proprietor evaluates that narrower position before filing and gathers evidence of the additional feature. The litigation strategy can then protect the commercially important product segment without depending entirely on the broadest claim.
Related guidance
Defending an Infringement Claim · Revocation Counterclaims · Choosing a UPC Division · Damages and Accounting
Legal framework and sources
Articles 25–26, 32–34, 47 and 63–69 UPCA.
Agreement on a Unified Patent Court · Current UPC legal documents and Rules of Procedure
Discuss your patent matter
For an initial enquiry, identify the patent, the product or process and any known court or launch deadline. Please leave out confidential technical details until conflicts have been checked.