Evidence Preservation and Inspections

English · Deutsch · Français

Evidence-preservation measures and inspections can secure technical facts that would otherwise be difficult to prove. At the UPC, they are judicial measures with defined conditions, safeguards and follow-on obligations. They are not a general entitlement to search a competitor’s business for potentially useful information.

In this guide: Identify the fact that needs to be preserved · Support the application with available evidence · Design a proportionate inspection protocol · Explain any request to proceed without notice · Manage the report and follow-on proceedings

Illustrative precision metal components and an industrial optical sensor

Identify the fact that needs to be preserved

Start with a specific evidential gap in the infringement case. Explain which claim feature is at issue, where the evidence is likely to be found and why ordinary publicly available material is insufficient. A sample, machine configuration, process record or short-lived demonstration may justify a different measure. The application should connect the requested activity to the alleged infringement and define its scope precisely enough for an appointed person to carry it out.

Support the application with available evidence

Article 60 UPCA requires reasonably available evidence supporting actual or imminent infringement. It permits measures such as detailed description, samples, seizure and inspection in the circumstances provided by the Agreement. The application should distinguish known facts from the inference it asks the court to investigate. A plausible technical connection is essential. The procedure should not be used to obtain broad commercial intelligence unrelated to the asserted patent.

Design a proportionate inspection protocol

Specify the premises, equipment, documents or samples concerned and the proposed safeguards. Consider how the inspection can avoid unrelated trade secrets, personal data and unnecessary production interruption. The Agreement restricts the applicant’s own attendance at an inspection and provides for a court-appointed person. A workable protocol may need to address independent professional participation, copying, sealing, reporting, access and permitted use. These details can determine whether the resulting evidence is reliable and fairly obtained.

Explain any request to proceed without notice

An application without hearing the other side needs a particular justification, such as a demonstrable risk of destruction or irreparable harm from delay. General concern that a competitor will defend itself is not enough. The affected party has review rights under the applicable procedure. Security and possible compensation must be considered. Applicants should assess those consequences before seeking a measure that could interrupt operations or expose confidential material.

Manage the report and follow-on proceedings

Preserved material may be subject to restrictions on access and use. Check the order before circulating it within the business or to experts. The Agreement provides time limits for bringing proceedings on the merits and consequences if they are not brought; calculate the applicable deadline from the actual order and rules. Defendants should preserve their objections, identify material outside the authorised scope and seek appropriate confidentiality or review measures promptly.

Four practical examples

These hypothetical examples explain typical decisions and evidence issues. They do not describe client matters or predict a court outcome.

1. A production line cannot be observed externally

A patent owner has product analysis suggesting a particular manufacturing step but cannot see the process. It seeks a targeted inspection of the relevant part of the line, supported by that analysis. The proposed protocol excludes unrelated production and addresses sensitive process information. The request is tied to a claim feature, not the competitor’s entire factory.

2. A trade fair exhibit will soon leave Europe

A machine is displayed briefly and then scheduled for export. The applicant explains the evidential opportunity, identifies the model and proposes a limited description or sampling measure. The time pressure is supported by concrete event facts. The application still needs a substantiated infringement basis and appropriate safeguards.

3. A defendant’s confidential data is mixed with relevant records

An inspection captures files containing both disputed technical settings and unrelated customer information. The defendant asks for controlled access and separation of irrelevant material under the order and applicable procedure. The issue is addressed before unrestricted circulation, preserving the ability to contest infringement without unnecessary commercial disclosure.

4. The applicant overlooks the merits deadline

Evidence has been secured, but settlement discussions continue. The legal team tracks the deadline for commencing the merits action independently of the negotiations. It considers the risk that the measure may be revoked and compensation sought if the required action is not brought. Successful evidence collection is only one stage of the procedure.

Related guidance

Orders to Produce Evidence · Confidentiality and Court Records · Preliminary Injunctions · Product and Process Patents

Legal framework and sources

Articles 58–60 UPCA; Rules 192–199 of the UPC Rules of Procedure.

Agreement on a Unified Patent Court · Current UPC legal documents and Rules of Procedure

Discuss your patent matter

For an initial enquiry, identify the patent, the product or process and any known court or launch deadline. Please leave out confidential technical details until conflicts have been checked.