Patent Licensing, Settlement and Mediation

English · Deutsch · Français

A patent licence or settlement should provide usable commercial certainty. That requires precise drafting of the rights, products, users, territory, payments and treatment of existing disputes. Mediation can help the parties reach an agreement, but the resulting bargain still needs a complete legal and operational structure.

In this guide: Define the rights and permitted activity · Allocate supply-chain and group coverage · Build a workable payment and reporting mechanism · Close litigation through an explicit completion plan · Choose mediation or arbitration for the right issues · Provide for change and termination

Define the rights and permitted activity

Identify patents, applications, divisionals and any future rights included in the licence. Specify products, processes, fields of use, territory and term. Address making, having made, importing, selling and customer use where relevant. Confirm the licensor’s title and authority and whether co-owner consent is needed. A reference to ‘all relevant patents’ can create uncertainty if the parties have not agreed which portfolio, entities and future developments it covers.

Allocate supply-chain and group coverage

Clarify the position of affiliates, contract manufacturers, distributors and customers. Determine whether sublicensing is permitted and how acquired or divested businesses are treated. Review exhaustion and authorised downstream use under the applicable law rather than relying only on a commercial label. Indemnities, warranties and limitations of liability allocate contractual risk but cannot grant rights the licensor does not possess. The licence should reflect the way the product is actually made and sold.

Build a workable payment and reporting mechanism

Define the royalty base, rate, deductions, currency, reporting period and treatment of returns, bundled products and intercompany transfers. Address minimum payments, milestones or lump sums where agreed. Audit provisions should be proportionate and protect sensitive information. Consider the effect of expiry, invalidity, territorial changes and portfolio additions. Avoid a payment formula that cannot be implemented using the licensee’s ordinary accounting records.

Close litigation through an explicit completion plan

A settlement should distinguish releases for past conduct from licences for future activity. Identify every pending action, counterclaim, appeal and opposition and the required steps in each forum. Address costs, interim orders, securities and accrued payment obligations. Under the UPC framework, settlement can be recognised through the relevant procedure, but the Agreement limits revocation or limitation of patents through settlement and mediation. A private agreement should not be described as itself revoking the patent with effect against everyone.

Choose mediation or arbitration for the right issues

Mediation allows a neutral to assist negotiations without imposing a decision. Arbitration is a different consensual process leading to an award within the applicable agreement and law. Assess confidentiality, enforceability, technical expertise, urgency and the arbitrability of the issues. Keep court deadlines and limitation risks under control while discussions continue. Competition-law review may be important, particularly for market allocation, restrictions on challenges or pharmaceutical settlements.

Provide for change and termination

Address breach, cure periods, insolvency, assignment, change of control and termination consequences. Decide what happens to existing stock, installed products, customer rights and accrued royalties. Include a mechanism for resolving disputes about reporting or scope before they become a new infringement conflict. For long-term technology relationships, define improvements and future patents carefully so that collaboration does not create a fresh ownership dispute.

Four practical examples

These hypothetical examples explain typical decisions and evidence issues. They do not describe client matters or predict a court outcome.

1. A component licence must protect customers

A supplier negotiates a licence but its customers use the component in larger systems. The parties identify the authorised downstream activity and any excluded system claims. This prevents the supplier from promising broader clearance than the licence actually provides.

2. A settlement spans several proceedings

The commercial terms are agreed while UPC infringement, a revocation counterclaim and EPO opposition remain pending. The agreement lists each proceeding, the responsible party, costs and the required procedural steps. Payment and procedural completion are coordinated so that no case is unintentionally left open.

3. Mediation reveals a business solution

Two competitors initially seek exclusion from the market, but mediation identifies a field-of-use licence and technical cooperation opportunity. The mediator does not decide patent validity. Counsel converts the commercial understanding into precise rights, payment and confidentiality obligations while preserving necessary procedural deadlines.

4. A licence ends while products remain installed

Termination raises questions about stock, maintenance and customer use of systems already supplied. The agreement addresses those consequences in advance and distinguishes continuing customer rights from new sales. This reduces the chance that termination unexpectedly disrupts customers or creates a new infringement dispute.

Related guidance

SEPs and FRAND Disputes · Damages and Accounting · Opt-Outs and Withdrawals · Cross-Border Patent Litigation

Legal framework and sources

Articles 35 and 79 UPCA; applicable contract, patent, competition and arbitration law.

UPC Agreement · WIPO: mediation and arbitration procedures

Discuss your patent matter

For an initial enquiry, identify the patent, the product or process and any known court or launch deadline. Please leave out confidential technical details until conflicts have been checked.