Product and process patents require different infringement evidence. A product may be examined directly, while a manufacturing or software process can be hidden from view. The litigation strategy should begin by identifying the claim category, the accused implementation and the evidence needed for each technical step.
In this guide: Read the claim category precisely · Preserve representative product evidence · Investigate process evidence lawfully · Consider directly obtained products and proof rules · Coordinate the technical and territorial analysis

Read the claim category precisely
A patent may contain product, apparatus, process, use and purpose-limited claims, each with a different scope. Do not infer the protected subject matter from the title or abstract. Identify the asserted claims and the technical relationships they require. A device capable of a process is not necessarily equivalent to proof that the process was performed. Conversely, a product claim may be relevant without showing the precise manufacturing route used.
Preserve representative product evidence
For a physical product, document purchase, model number, serial number, packaging and condition before testing. Record modifications caused by teardown or analysis. Where software or firmware affects operation, preserve the relevant version and settings. Consider whether the sample represents the period and territories in dispute. A well-documented test of the wrong version can be less useful than a modest test tied reliably to the accused sales.
Investigate process evidence lawfully
Process steps may be shown by technical documentation, admissions, product characteristics, expert analysis or court-ordered evidence measures. Explain the inferential chain and its limits. A final product’s properties may be compatible with several manufacturing routes. Where evidence lies with the defendant, assess targeted production or preservation rather than asserting an unrestricted right to inspect. Confidentiality protection is often central to making the process evidence usable.
Consider directly obtained products and proof rules
Article 25(c) UPCA addresses products obtained directly by a patented process. Article 55 contains specific burden-of-proof rules concerning identical products and process patents, subject to its conditions and protection of manufacturing and trade secrets. Those rules do not mean that every process allegation automatically reverses the burden. Analyse the statutory requirements, what reasonable investigative efforts were made and whether the product was obtained directly by the process.
Coordinate the technical and territorial analysis
A process may involve steps in different facilities or countries, particularly in cloud computing or international manufacturing. Identify who performs each step, where and with what control. Assess the legal significance under the applicable law instead of assuming that a cross-border arrangement either automatically infringes or automatically avoids liability. The same factual map helps define a workable injunction and assess potential redesigns.
Four practical examples
These hypothetical examples explain typical decisions and evidence issues. They do not describe client matters or predict a court outcome.
1. Two routes produce similar material
A chemical analysis shows that the accused material has the expected final properties, but more than one process could produce them. The claimant investigates which characteristics genuinely distinguish the patented route. The defendant preserves batch records and considers confidentiality measures for explaining its alternative process.
2. Firmware changes the relevant operation
A machine’s hardware remains unchanged, but a firmware update alters the sequence of processing steps. The parties identify which version was sold or used during the alleged period. A test of the latest software is not treated as conclusive evidence about earlier installations.
3. An imported product may be directly obtained by a process
A European importer purchases goods manufactured abroad. The legal analysis considers whether the goods are obtained directly by the claimed process and the relevant import acts. The foreign manufacturing location is not used as a blanket answer to the product-by-process enforcement issue.
4. A cloud process is distributed across countries
A connected device sends data to servers in another jurisdiction before receiving a result. Counsel maps each claimed step, the responsible entities and the technical control. This supports a specific territorial analysis instead of relying on the location of the user interface alone.
Related guidance
Direct and Indirect Infringement · Evidence Preservation and Inspections · Orders to Produce Evidence · Software, AI and Electronics Patents
Legal framework and sources
Articles 25, 54–55 and 58–60 UPCA; Article 69 EPC.
Agreement on a Unified Patent Court · Current UPC legal documents and Rules of Procedure
Discuss your patent matter
For an initial enquiry, identify the patent, the product or process and any known court or launch deadline. Please leave out confidential technical details until conflicts have been checked.